Male Pattern Fitness: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: Backing the Pack for NC State Fans!


Revealed: Ice Cream Is Health Food!

In the current issue of Newsweek, the cover story about diet and fertility has this subhead: "In a groundbreaking new book, Harvard researchers look at the role of diet, exercise and weight control in fertility. Guarantee: you will be surprised."

Personally, I'd describe the information as "interesting," rather than surprising. (Can I get my money back?) Take the conclusion about carbohydrates, for example:

In a nutshell, results from the Nurses' Health Study indicate that the amount of carbohydrates in the diet doesn't affect fertility, but the quality of those carbohydrates does. Eating a lot of rapidly digested carbohydrates that continually boost your blood-sugar and insulin levels higher can lower your chances of getting pregnant. This is especially true if you are eating carbohydrates in place of healthful unsaturated fats. On the other hand, eating whole grains, beans, vegetables and whole fruits -- all of which are good sources of slowly digested carbohydrates -- can improve ovulation and your chances of getting pregnant.

I understand that this correlation came up in a big, well-designed study, and that's important. So I don't mean any disrespect to the Harvard researchers when I say this, but who in the world would've thought that eating white bread and washing it down with Mountain Dew was a good idea?

When I was working on The New Rules of Lifting for Women, I was surprised by the links between diet, exercise, and reproductive hormones. When a woman is exercising in a serious way -- training for a sport, for example -- a change in her menstrual cycle is a pretty good indication that there's something wrong. Usually, it's a mismatch between diet and activity level -- not enough food replacing the energy that's being drained by her workouts.

So, intuitively, it makes sense that a mismatch in the other direction -- too much energy coming in, or the wrong kind -- would affect fertility.

Again, I understand how important it is to quantify what we could guess using intuition and some basic knowledge. I just reserve the right to not be surprised.

Similarly, I wasn't surprised by the conclusion about fat -- trans fats are the only type associated with fertility problems -- but I suspect a lot of other people will find themselves with blown minds when they read this:

A related issue is whether dietary fats influence ovulation and reproduction. We were shocked to discover that this was largely uncharted territory. Until now, only a few studies have explored this connection. They focused mainly on the relationship between fat intake and characteristics of the menstrual cycle, such as cycle length and the duration of different phases of the cycle. In general, these studies suggest that more fat in the diet, and in some cases more saturated fat, improves the menstrual cycle. ...

The Nurses' Health Study research team looked for connections between dietary fats and fertility from a number of different angles. Among the 18,555 women in the study, the total amount of fat in the diet wasn't connected with ovulatory infertility once weight, exercise, smoking and other factors that can influence reproduction had been accounted for. The same was true for cholesterol, saturated fat and monounsaturated fat -- none were linked with fertility or infertility.

So saturated fat and cholesterol aren't linked to fertility problems, and may actually help normalize a woman's reproductive hormones. This, of course, makes perfect sense when you consider that estrogen is a steroid hormone, and all steroid hormones are made from cholesterol. If estrogen is the master hormone affecting a woman's reproductive health, why wouldn't you build a healthy diet around foods rich in saturated fat, which tend to have relatively high amounts of cholesterol?

Unfortunately, animal protein is associated with lower fertility, according to the study. Protein from plant sources -- beans and nuts -- seems to have the opposite effect. Beans really are the magical fruit! (Okay, technically they aren't fruit. But it's hard for kids to find a synonym for flatulence that rhymes with "legume." *)

But then there's another seemingly contradictory finding: Full-fat ice cream and dairy products are linked to improved fertility; low-fat versions reduce it. Once again, there's that link between saturated fat -- found in abundance in dairy products -- and reproductive health.

I confess: Even though I'm not female, I get unusually excited whenever I see a health benefit linked to ice cream. (Or butter, or chocolate ...)

* To my shame, I think I just created one: "Beans, beans, the magical legume. The more you eat, the faster you clear the room."

Wednesday blog meat

  • From good news to bad: Obesity can have tragic consequences for pregnant women. (Hat tip: Rannoch Donald.)
  • Here's a fascinating explanation of why flu viruses thrive in cold, dry weather. Conversely, they can barely survive in the tropics. When's the last time you saw a health benefit linked to humidity?
  • My wife was excited to learn that Cindy Crawford has stretch marks. Me, not so much.

0 recs | Comment 2 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Some pretty unsurprising news there...
...but on a related note, this article correllating low birth weight--and the general health of mothers when they give birth--with heart disease in their offspring MUCH later in life, IS actually pretty amazing (only the abstract is available online, sadly):

http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/11/19/071119fa_fact_hall

andrew@dynamicfitness.us blog.dynamicfitness.us www.dynamicfitness.us

by Andrew on Dec 5, 2007 11:25 AM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Book isn't consistent with data
Yet in the book that is being promoted they recommend saturated fat be limited to just 8% or less of calories each day (no data to support it though) when their subjects with the lower risk of infertility consumed 11.5% of calories from saturated fat.

by Regina Wilshire on Dec 5, 2007 11:27 AM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about exercise, nutrition, health, and weight control
Start posting on Male Pattern Fitness »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

122857_red_sox_angels_baseball_small
Hot or cold water for maximum weight loss?
India_etc_214_small
Question about Tiredness/Soreness and Help With Workout
Cards_small
Anyone tried Leukic Hardcore and / or Gakic Harcore?
Small
Wall Sits
Helmet_small
Anyone Used or Know Much About P90X?
The_muscle_small
Its that time of year...
Small
Question about Trunk Twists
Npk_small
patlombwmu heres a suggestion
Moustache__small
Question About Personal Training Certifications
Kearse_jevon0108_1__small
A workout i fianlly think y'all will agree with!

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Westside_select_2_small Lou Schuler

Photo_125_small Andrew Heffernan

Official Partner of Yahoo! Sports